Patients, clinicians, organizations, policies and resources all interact in ways that influence health outcomes. Understanding those interactions is essential for improving patient care and health systems.
Health system science is the study of how healthcare is delivered, how health professionals work together, and how health systems can be improved.
Alongside the basic sciences and clinical sciences, health systems serve as the 3rd pillar of modern medical science. Health system science is composed of 12 domains patient, family, and community.
Health care structure and process. Health policy and economics, value in health care, clinical informatics and health technology, population, public and determinants of health.
Health system improvement. Ethics and legal change agency management and advocacy.
Teaming, leadership, and systems thinking. Among these, systems thinking is especially important because it helps clinicians understand how many parts of a healthcare system interact and influence one another.
Systems thinking is a holistic approach to understanding a system's component parts and how those parts are connected in order to better understand how the system works and evolves over time.
It pays attention to the complex web of interdependencies between parts of a system, the whole system rather than just the parts, and multidirectional cause and effect relationships where every cause is also the effect of another system dynamic.
It's helpful to contrast this with linear thinking. Linear thinking looks for a single cause at a single point in time.
Systems thinking looks for patterns and relationships, even as they change over time. Linear thinking approaches problems in a logical, sequential manner.
If there's a challenge, the goal is to identify the issue, apply a solution, and reach an expected result. Linear thinking works well for simple, predictable processes.
But it tends to break down in healthcare, where the same input often produces very different outputs, depending on the context, the people, and the timing.
Let's see this in practice. The emergency department has been overcrowded for months.
Doctor Patel, the medical director, has been asked to address the problem. A linear approach would suggest the obvious solution add more beds.
Doctor Patel asks a different question instead. Why does overcrowding exist in the first place?
Her team maps the patient flow and finds that the bottleneck isn't actually in the emergency department. It's on the inpatient floors where slow discharges are blocking admissions, which keeps patients stuck in the emergency department.
Adding more emergency department beds wouldn't fix the underlying problem, but redesigning the discharge process would. To understand why Doctor Patel's approach worked, we first need a clear sense of what is a health system.
The World Health Organization or WHO defines a health system as the sum of all the organizations, institutions, and resources whose primary purpose is to improve health.
It includes hospitals, clinics, insurers, pharmaceutical companies, public health agencies, and sectors outside healthcare that influence health like agriculture, education, and transport.
A health delivery system is narrower. It refers specifically to the organizations and people that deliver care to patients, like hospitals, clinics, ambulatory practices, home health services, and the clinicians who work in them.
The WHO describes a health system through 6 building blocks. These include service delivery or the way care reaches patients, the health workforce, or the people who provide care, health information systems or the data and evidence behind decisions, medical products ranging from vaccines to technologies.
Health financing or the way care is paid for and leadership and governance or the rules and oversight that hold the system together.
Because health systems contain many interconnected people, organizations and processes that continuously influence one another, they are considered complex systems.
A complex system is one in which many parts interact in many different ways, often unpredictably, and where the behavior of the whole emerges from those interactions rather than from the parts alone.
Complex systems share a few key features. They are made up of networks of people and processes that exchange information.
They self-organize. They show emergence, meaning the system as a whole behaves in a way no single part would predict.
And small changes in initial conditions can produce large and unpredictable outcomes downstream. Healthcare delivery is widely described as a complex adaptive system.
It involves many interacting professionals, departments, organizations, and external sectors that continuously influence one another and change over time.
Because of these interactions, the same intervention may produce different outcomes in different settings at different times.
Additionally, many factors affecting health exist outside the healthcare system itself, reinforcing the need for a systems perspective.
So, how do clinicians apply systems thinking in a complex healthcare environment? System thinkers develop habits that help them understand relationships within a system and identify opportunities for improvement.
Some are especially important in health care. First is seeking to understand the big picture.
A systems thinker steps back and looks at how the parts of a system fit together rather than focusing on a single piece in isolation.
A clinician who only treats the asthma exacerbation in front of them might miss that the patient cannot afford the inhaler and will be back in the emergency department next month.
Next is identifying the circular nature of complex cause and effect. Cause and effect in healthcare is rarely a one-way street.
Most clinical problems involve feedback loops where one part of the system influences another, which then feeds back to influence the first.
Causal loop diagrams help map these relationships. Another habit is changing perspectives to increase understanding.
Different roles in the system see different parts of it. A nurse, a pharmacist, a surgeon, and an administrator may all see the same patient through different lenses, and a systems thinker actively seeks those views.
System thinkers also surface and test assumptions. Clinicians make assumptions every day.
Those assumptions are based on experience, but they can also block clear thinking and lead to incorrect conclusions. System thinkers slow down and check whether their assumptions actually match the facts.
They also consider consequences including short term, long term, and unintended consequences. A change that solves a problem today can create a new problem next month.
Systems thinkers ask, what else does a proposed change do, especially in parts of the system that aren't the obvious target.
A hallmark of systems thinking is to consider how things change over time. What was the case a month ago may not be true next month.
Systems thinkers take into account the adaptive nature of complex healthcare systems. Finally, systems thinkers consider an issue fully and resist the urge to come to a quick conclusion.
Quick fixes can ease pressure in the short-term, but often leave the underlying system problem in place, which means the issue resurfaces in a different form.
Let's see how several of these habits come together in practice. Ben, a physician assistant on the hospital medicine team, notices that 30 day readmissions for heart failure have been rising.
A linear response might focus only on the discharge instructions or add a follow-up phone call. Ben takes a systems approach instead.
He maps the patient journey from admission to discharge to community follow-up. Rather than assuming the cause of the problem, he asks each team member what they see from their perspective.
They find a feedback loop. Patients are being discharged before their diuretic doses are stable, which leads to fluid buildup at home.
This causes more readmissions that put pressure on the inpatient team, which leads to faster discharges next time. By redesigning the discharge criteria, adding a follow-up call within 48 hours, and creating a feedback channel from the community team back to the inpatient team, the readmission rate falls.
So, in this case, Ben looked beyond the obvious problem, sought multiple perspectives, identified a feedback loop, and considered how different parts of the system influenced one another.
Note that the next time readmissions for heart failure rise, as a systems thinker, Ben won't assume the same causal feedback loop, because adaptive systems change over time, he'll make a new map of the patient journey.
Now that we've discussed how systems thinkers approach complex problems, let's see why systems thinking is so important in healthcare.
Many challenges in healthcare cannot be traced to a single person, process or decision. Instead, they arise from the way people, processes, resources, and policies interact within a larger system.
Clinicians who think in systems are better at finding the real sources of a problem rather than the obvious one. They're better at predicting what a proposed change will actually do.
They're better at working across professions and departments because they recognize that the patient's outcome depends on coordination across the whole system.
And they're better at improving care because they target the parts of the system where change actually has leverage. In a healthcare system that is complex and constantly changing, systems thinking helps clinicians move beyond quick fixes and create more lasting improvements.
Alright, as a quick recap, health systems science focuses on how healthcare is delivered and improved. Systems thinking is a holistic approach to understanding how the parts of a system interact and influence one another over time.
Unlike linear thinking, which looks for a single cause, systems thinking looks for patterns, relationships, and feedback loops.
A health system includes all organizations, institutions and resources whose primary purpose is to improve health, while a health delivery system refers specifically to those that provide care.
Because health systems are complex adaptive systems, systems thinkers focus on the big picture, include multiple perspectives, consider changes over time, test assumptions, and anticipate unintended consequences.
Notes
COMPLEXITY AND SYSTEMS THINKING
Key Term
Definition
Example
Health Systems Science
The study of how healthcare is delivered, how health professionals work together, and how health systems can be improved.
Systems Thinking
A holistic approach to understanding a system's component parts and how those parts are connected in order to better understand how the system works and evolves over time.
Clinical team looks beyond emergency department crowding itself and traces the problem to slow discharges on the inpatient floors.
Linear Thinking
A logical, sequential approach that identifies a problem, applies a solution, and expects a predictable result.
Adding more emergency department beds to fix overcrowding.
Health System
The sum of all the organizations, institutions, and resources whose primary purpose is to improve health.
Health Delivery System
The narrower group of organizations and people that directly deliver care to patients.
Complex System
A system in which many parts interact in many different ways, often unpredictably, and where the behavior of the whole emerges from those interactions rather than from the parts alone.
Understanding the Big Picture
The habit of stepping back and looking at how the parts of a system fit together rather than focusing on a single piece in isolation.
A clinician treating an asthma exacerbation also recognizes that the patient cannot afford the inhaler and may return to the emergency department next month.
Identifying the Circular Nature of Complex Cause and Effect
The habit of recognizing that cause and effect in healthcare are rarely one-way and often involve feedback loops.
Patients are discharged before diuretic doses are stable, which leads to readmission, which puts pressure on the inpatient team, which then leads to faster discharges next time.
Changing Perspectives to Increase Understanding
The habit of seeking different viewpoints because different roles in the system see different parts of it.
A clinician asks each team member what they see from their perspective when examining rising heart failure readmissions.
Surfacing And Testing Assumptions
The habit of slowing down and checking whether assumptions actually match the facts.
Rather than assuming discharge instructions are the main problem, the clinician maps the patient journey and asks the team what they observe.
Considering Consequences
The habit of thinking about short-term, long-term, and unintended consequences before making a change.
Systems thinkers ask what else a proposed change might do in other parts of the system, not just the obvious target.
Resisting the Urge to Come to a Quick Conclusion
The habit of considering an issue fully instead of relying on a quick fix that may leave the deeper system problem in place.
Adding more emergency department beds might ease pressure briefly, but it would not fix the upstream discharge bottleneck.
Sources
"Leadership and Nursing Care Management. 7th ed. " Elsevier (2021)
"Ballweg's Physician Assistant: A Guide to Clinical Practice. 7th ed. " Elsevier (2021)
"Essentials of Global Health. 1st ed. " Elsevier (2018)
"Health Systems Science. 2nd ed. " Elsevier (2020)
No notes for this video yet
Try adding a note below
Transcript
Patients, clinicians, organizations, policies, and resources all interact in ways that influence health outcomes. Understanding those interactions is essential for improving patient care and health systems.
Health systems science is the study of how healthcare is delivered, how health professionals work together, and how health systems can be improved.
Alongside the basic sciences and clinical sciences, health systems serves as the third pillar of modern medical science.
Health systems science is composed of 12 domains: patient, family, and community; health care structure and process; health policy and economics; value in health care; clinical informatics and health technology; population, public, and determinants of health; health system improvement; ethics and legal; change agency, management, and advocacy; teaming; leadership; and systems thinking.
Among these, systems thinking is especially important because it helps clinicians understand how many parts of a healthcare system interact and influence one another. Systems thinking is a holistic approach to understanding a system's component parts and how those parts are connected, in order to better understand how the system works and evolves over time. It pays attention to the complex web of interdependencies between parts of a system, the whole system rather than just the parts, and multidirectional cause-and-effect relationships, where every cause is also the effect of another system dynamic.
It's helpful to contrast this with linear thinking. Linear thinking looks for a single cause at a single point in time; systems thinking looks for patterns and relationships, even as they change over time. Linear thinking approaches problems in a logical, sequential manner. If there's a challenge, the goal is to identify the issue, apply a solution, and reach an expected result. Linear thinking works well for simple, predictable processes. But it tends to break down in healthcare, where the same input often produces very different outputs depending on the context, the people, and the timing.
Let's see this in practice.
The emergency department has been overcrowded for months. Dr. Patel, the medical director, has been asked to address the problem. A linear approach would suggest the obvious solution: add more beds. Dr. Patel asks a different question instead: why does overcrowding exist in the first place? Her team maps the patient flow and finds that the bottleneck isn't actually in the emergency department. It's on the inpatient floors, where slow discharges are blocking admissions, which keeps patients stuck in the emergency department. Adding more emergency department beds wouldn't fix the underlying problem, but redesigning the discharge process would.